Test Drive Gadget Reviews with Bill and Phil

The New iPad Pro: Major Upgrade or Minor Improvement?

Bill has loved his iPad Pro ever since he bought the first one in late 2015. And when he bought the Magic Keyboard in 2020, he was in fancy tablet nirvana.

Bill & Phil

In May, when Apple announced the 7th generation version — complete with a slightly larger 13-inch screen and a much faster M4 chip — his trembling hands could barely hold his credit card still. (So, he paid with Apple Pay — all he had to do was double-click.)

As he unboxed his new iPad (with the new Magic Keyboard and new Apple Pencil), Bill’s heart was racing so fast, his body thought he had taken up triathlons again. He couldn’t wait to show it to Phil.

Phil (a self-professed Apple naysayer) watched Bill’s impressive demo of his new love. “So, what does it do that your old one won’t do?” Phil asked.  Bill was uncharacteristically at a loss for words. He finally responded, “Nothing new. It just does everything better and faster.”

Phil finally agreed that Bill’s new iPad was somewhat faster, and the display seemed clearer and a bit more vibrant. But for Phil, the question was whether those upgrades were worth spending $1,500. So we dug a bit deeper.

The new iPad Pro is the thinnest Apple product, and one of the thinnest devices on the market. Apple did change the location of the front-facing camera, making it ideal for Zoom and Teams meetings. The new M4 chip is the fastest processor Apple makes. It handles anything you can give it at blazing speed. Certainly, if you are a video editor, it is a delight to use. However, for most tasks, one can hardly tell the difference between its speed and that of previous iPads or any other recently made tablet or laptop.

“The new iPad Pro is the thinnest Apple product, and one of the thinnest devices on the market. Apple did change the location of the front-facing camera, making it ideal for Zoom and Teams meetings.”

There is also a new pencil, the Apple Pencil Pro. An Apple Pencil of any generation is a handy tool, if one is so inclined. You can sign and mark up documents, make hand-written notes, create drawings in emails, etc. But the new features of the Pencil Pro are not so revolutionary unless you are a prolific illustrator.  There are slight note-taking improvements that may or may not be worth paying $129 for a new Pro model.

The new Ultra Retina XDR Display is impressive. Apple says it is the “most advanced display in the world.” (Phil is skeptical of that claim.) It’s very bright and vibrant, and the colors are amazing. The image quality is great even in situations where there is a lot of glare.

But Bill is a lawyer, and an old one at that. He uses the same software on his new iPad Pro as he used on his old one. As Phil so critically pointed out, “Bill cannot do anything on the iPad Pro 7th Generation that he could not do on his old 4th generation model. And, his brain is so slow, the speed of his iPad is not the bottleneck.”

Bill begs to differ. He uses the iPad for videoconferences on Zoom, Teams and Google Meet, so it’s true that the new camera location is a plus. He also uses the new features of the Pencil Pro. At least in his mind, the new iPad Pro is noticeably faster.

So despite his disagreements, Phil will let Bill enjoy his Apple products to his heart’s desire. After all, beauty and functionality are all in the eye of the beholder. As Bill said, “Phil, my pickup can drive down the road just like your Lexus does.” Whatever, Bill.